DKaz... Some great comments.
I wish I could remember what the circumstances were around first posting the poll 4 years ago. I think it came about when someone mentioned they would like to see test / reviews of summer tires done similar to the Real World Snow Tire Tests.
The reason I started the Snow Tire FAQ some 15 years ago was to help people understand that
AWD, ABS, and Traction Control do eliminate the need for snow tires, and All Season tires do not replace snow tires. (I sometimes use the simple analogy: You put boots on instead of sandles to walk in the snow, shouldn't you do the same with your car's tires?)
I started the Real World Snow Tire Tests in response to seeing tire tests that featured "perfect" conditions that you or I would never see. Other popular reviews, especially the ones found on major tire reseller websites, only dealt with tires that were sold by the companies. I wanted to do something a bit different, more in lines with how Consumer Union does testing, but also from the point of view of someone who is looking for that performance edge.
The Forums were started in a reaction to the number of questions I was getting. The thoughts were simple: (1) have a place where people can see what was asked. (2) share information amongst others (two heads is better than one, so many heads....). All in all, I think it has achieved those goals, but I wouldn't mind seeing it more active.
So, back to the topic: a page about summer tires. I really like the idea of saying something, but also making sure it focuses back on the "All Seasons are not Snow Tires" and "If you drive in the snow, you need snow tires." While it would be nice to be doing reviews of summer (or even all season tires), that's not the core of this site, and I think the current climate suggests focusing back on core things and getting rid of all of the distractions (that's been a theme in my life for just about a years now).
- John